From: "L-Soft list server at Indiana University (1.8d)" To: "ARTF@MemoryAlpha.nil" File: "LOISCLA-GENERAL-L LOG9709D" ========================================================================= Date: Mon, 22 Sep 1997 01:12:02 -0400 Reply-To: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" Sender: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" From: The Zoomway Subject: Re: Ideas In a message dated 97-09-21 19:38:08 EDT, jernigan@COMPUSERVE.COM writes: << I immediately thought of Zoomway's "If you can't beat 'em (Joe's Story)" and "Join 'em" by Kari Umbrect?? I still don't like the original (sorry, Zoomway! ) but the sequel is very nice, and fits nicely with the original. >> Hey, I caught hell for that story I told Joe it would happen, but he was willing to take any heat for the story, and I said "Okay, it's your baby", but I don't regret writing it even though it made some readers uncomfortable (okay, with Leigh I got a 14 page scolding ;) I followed his outline to the letter and never asked to change one thing he wanted, I just wrote what he asked of me, and since he was happy, I guess the reaming I got over it was 'almost' worth it I got positive and negative feedback on the story, but this, from part of Leigh Raglan's 14 page scolding was the much more typical response. "This is wrong! There is no way, shape or form that would cause Clark Kent to live a lie and a sexual relationship with Lois Lane as Superman!" I agree with Leigh on this, but reminded her that it was a story I was writing for someone else and to his specifications. She wrote back and told me I should have just refused, but there are fanfic readers out there that do have ideas, but they either haven't the time, or say they haven't the talent for writing, but would love to see an idea of theirs turned into fanfic, and I try and accommodate requests like that when I can. Most aren't nearly as specific as Joe. Angie, for example, wanted to see the date Lois and Clark made at the end of Individual Responsibility that we never saw on the screen. Her only request? That it take place in an Indian restaurant. So, I was pretty much on my own with how I wanted to handle that story (12:01) Or, Becky had just bought some Superman bubble bath and said she'd like to have a story involving a bubble bath, and so I wrote Dirty Bubbles. Some stopped reading that short story after the first paragraph indicated Lois was married to Lex Luthor It's not always easy writing a story to another person's expectations (hey, didn't L&C discusss expectations ;) but if they're happy with the end result, that's what makes it worth the shots when it's finished. I always send it to them first so that if there's anything they want changed, or done differently, I'm happy to oblige, it's their story and they deserve to have it say what they want in the way they want it said. There's two exceptions to the "on request" fanfic I'm willing to write. I won't write any story where Lois or Clark cheats on the other, nor will I write "death fic". I don't like either type and so I'd find it fairly impossible to write either type I sometimes forget the older fanfic I've written if it was written for someone else, and Joe's story was written back in 94 before Metallo even aired. I do believe though when a reader gets upset by a story if they think it goes contrary to the characters that the show established, that the series did a great job creating a universe and characters that are so well understood by the fans that said fans get upset if they feel that universe is upended. I personally don't think I have a problem with almost any type of fanfic (other than the cheating or death fic type) I like funny stuff, romantic stuff, and stuff that has a surprise or a twist to it. I don't like stories that ramble a lot (incluiding mine ;) with a zillion words of exposition. I think it was Moby Dick that did me in for that. I mean three pages describing the man's hat for crying out loud! I like stream of consciousness type writing if very well done, if not, it's about as rewarding and filling as a rice cake There is some fanfic that would make a horrible episode for the series, but is still great to read. It's like Stranger in a Strange Land. I think that would make a gosh awful movie, too much is in your head, but it's a mesmerizing novel to read if you like that kind of story. Most of the fiction I read, as you can probably tell, is science fiction and some fantasy. I have never read a romance novel of any type, or a western, or a James Bond type of intrigue/adventure novel. I think that's what I'd be interested in hearing on the fanfic list. What do the readers and writers read when they get an honest-to-goodness published novel? I'm curious truly because I remember in high school our English class had the choice of Fahrenheit 451, A Separate Peace and To Kill a Mocking Bird. I was the only female in the class to choose Fahrenheit 451 so I begin to wonder if I'm an anomaly among others of my gender Anyway, I'd really be interested in favorite novels, authors, genres, etc. Zoomway@aol.com ========================================================================= Date: Mon, 22 Sep 1997 01:41:12 -0400 Reply-To: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" Sender: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" From: Demona Subject: Re: Ideas In-Reply-To: <970922011200_1730482812@emout08.mail.aol.com> Mime-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset="us-ascii" At 01:12 AM 9/22/97 -0400, you wrote: >I won't write any story where >Lois or Clark cheats on the other, nor will I write "death fic". Nor will she write fic that I've been bugging her to write for months LOL Hi everyone! Yes I'm still alive!! Remember me? :) That reminds me of one of your other stories Squidgy, what was it called again? The one with IRC and Rapunzel? I know I asked for a sequel to that but I'm sure it's about as done as our co-compilation, or the one I'm doing with KathyB, or the other two I have started here, so I'm REALLY one to talk huh? *sigh* I absolultely need to take a few days off and write ;) That would be yummy! Demi (Who still absolutely loves Chris' Mulder's "meet me in kansas city" ;) _________________________________________________ Demi (a.k.a) Demona or http://www.wiznet.ca/~demona --- L&C Site http://www.netforward.com/cryogen/?LNC --- "Never underestimate the power of a star filled sky on a warm tropical night" - Perry White a la Zoomway _________________________________________________ ========================================================================= Date: Mon, 22 Sep 1997 05:15:34 -0400 Reply-To: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" Sender: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" From: The Zoomway Subject: Re: Looking for Lois Lane In a message dated 97-09-21 21:20:26 EDT, debby@SWCP.COM writes: << Jack, being of a cunning intelligence and knowing Clark's big secret, as well as being Clark's friend, would figure out ways to help Superman get done with the job quicker. Or, "support Clark's Superman side," if you wish. Knowing Superman's proclivity for falling into traps, Jack would think of ways to help him avoid them. >> To quote alternate Clark "This is exactly what I was afraid of" That sounds awfully close to Batman and his boy companion Robin ;) I was glad Jack vanished. >>>Some argue that he hadn't had a steady relationship before, and this may be the case<<< "Flying is a piece of cake. I've been doing it since high school. What happens if I screw up? I lose a little altitude, but being in a relationship, that's completely new..." So, yes, that was the case. He never had a relationship by his own admission. >>>However, I don't think this translates into the relationship he wants being hard to maintain. If he had not yet had such a relationship of his own, let's look at the most influenial relationship he experienced through observation, that of Martha and Jonathan<<<< How much worth was his parents as examples when it came to a courtship? Clark didn't know what his parents dating history was like. If anything, I think Clark's idealized vision of his parents relationship sometimes caused some unrealistic expectations for him.. He wanted instant 'happily ever after', but because he only saw the "after" with his parents, he had absolutely no clue what they went through to achieve that. >>>Clark could have solve that by simply telling Lois the truth<<< Telling Lois the truth only solved part of the problem (his dashing off appearing to be a fear of commitment, etc) but it still didn't give him relationship skills, and no matter how good an example Jon and Martha were, Jon was never two people who had to balance a job, being a superhero and a marriage. Martha didn't have to adjust to something like that either. Lois and Clark were on their on with that scenario. >>blundered into his relationship with Lois Lane and came out looking like a heavily stressed chunk of granite<<< I enjoyed their "blunders". It made their bliss all the more well earned ;) >>hen, seeing that his mind was made up and that he was going to make his announcement the next day, Lois rushed out to find a better solution. Which, of course, she did. Hooray, Lois<<< I think ultimately the decision has to be Clark's. I know it's supposed to be 50/50 in a marriage,. but there are some points where one partner has the ultimate decision to make and stand by. If a wife doesn't want any more children, but the husband does, I say ultimately *she* makes the decision because she is the one who has to endure the pregnancy. Now, if both men and women could get pregnant, that would be different. The wife could say, "Okay, you want another baby? It's your turn to get pregnant." Lois had a great deal to do with the creation and the maintainance of "Superman", but when push comes to shove, Clark is the one all alone out there having to make the decisions by himself, often in a split second. Jon and Martha made great points about Lois and Clark losing their privacy and Lois being known from there on out as "Superman's wife", but Lois accepts what might befall her and Clark if the truth comes out, what she *can't* accept is what happens to Superman if the truth comes out. She's trying to let Clark know that the truth could be as bad or worse for "Superman" as the scandal. Superman's "fate" can be discussed and argued by all parties who might be effected by "the truth", but ultimately the decision can't be made by committee, it is up to one person--Clark Kent. >>It took her most of the episode to say this, too. Yawn.<<< Having been married 16 years, I can tell you that it takes a lot longer than "most of the episode" sometimes to tell your husband what's upsetting you. This phrase, "Well, if you don't know what's wrong, I'm certainly not going to tell you" didn't become a cliche from lack of use I know it seems ludircrous to people who aren't married, but it is so close to the truth it's scary. You feel that your spouse should *know* what made you upset, and if he doensn't automatically know, then he doesn't care about your feelings Like I said, it probably sounds silly to someone who isn't married, but someone who *is* married could see a lot of theirself in Lois "suffering in silence" waiting for lunkhead to pick up the signal ;) One reason Lois drew the whole thing out is because she thought Clark knew about his molecular structure "stablizing and slowing" the aging process and she was angry he never told her. >>>He could also, of course, *die* the next day, anyone can, but particularly a fellow who throws himself into battling dangerous criminals.<<< That's also true, and Clark makes that point. >>>That's not what was said, that much I recall. His body had already compensated. It had made up the difference, he had revitalized, he was the same as before.<<< Well, here's the dialog, make of it what you will, but to me it sounds like Clark did "lose something". "Dr. Klein said my body has already compensated for the age drain." "Compensated? Then you have lost something." "My friend is healthy. I'm sitting here with my wife. I haven't lost anything." "You gave up years." "I gave them up for a friend." "How many?" "I don't know. The truth is, no one knows how long they've got. Anyway, it's not the years that count, it's the moments. Right now, as they happen." You'll recall right after Superman came out of the machine (after resetting Carter Shank to infancy and Jimmy back to a 22 year old) he said "I feel okay" Lois asks Doodsen "Is he?" and she says "It's too soon to tell" Remember that Jimmy looked fine right after he came out of the machine and the rapid aging took a while to start. Superman looked fine right when he came out, but because of his long lifespan, then even the 100+ years it cost him to restore Shank (over restore him ;) and Jimmy was something his body could "compensate" (counterbalance). That is, suppose you have a 50 year old man (want one? ;) and you age him five years. It's not likely that it'll make that big a difference in his appearance. However, if you take an infant and age *him* five years, the difference is startling. What I'm getting at is say that Superman's lifespan was 200 years, but then you take about 130 from that (to restore Shank and Jimmy) and his lifespan now becomes 70 years. In other words, Superman still had 70 years left to him, and so the "drain" wouldn't show on him. Whereas, you take Jimmy, whose lifespan is about 70 to begin with and take 50 years of that away from him, then he has no "years" left to compensate the loss. He's going to be an old man. I don't know if any of that made any sense, but Lois and Clark's dialog seems to indicate Clark did in fact lose years. >>>That's my very point. I certainly expect them to *try*, on the ceiling, on the kitchen floor, or wherever they wanted, and have lots of fun at it! But to go into the marriage assuming they could have kids<<< Before they got married, Lois was in the alternate world and Wells helped her recall their previous adventure, and in that adventure Wells tells Lois that Superman's descendants create Utopia. Wells also assures her that she "will be" good at handling babies. Then if we go back to The Foundling, perhaps Clark read too much into Jor-El saying that Earth was chosen because of its compatability with Krypton and its people. Either way, even human couples assume they can have children until they start trying and nothing happens. >>>I suspect that he did know. I wouldn't expect Clark to rat on Lois because I would expect Perry to already know about it.<<< Okay, let's assume that for whatever reason not indicated in the episode, Perry knew Lois stole the story and so *he* sent her on that wild goose chase through the sewage reclamation plant. A lot of the impact is immediately lost. With Perry having administered the comeuppance, then there is no new found respect for Clark from Lois for standing up to her, and Jimmy, who stood up to Perry being inspired by CK, would be lost as well. What we get instead is Lois being drubbed by her boss. So what? That just dilutes Lois's "punishment" to a sight gag with no real importance or impact. Then again, Perry might take a more professional route to a comeuppance and suspend her 2 weeks without pay. It says the same thing the other scenario would say "the boss won't tolerate stealing" and since the "goose chase" scene loses its impact anyway when administered by Perry, then it might as well be a more standard punishment for misconduct. >>>Clark, sitting quietly at his desk, speaking from the heart, looking right at Lois (note that the newsroom is nearly empty). "Lois, I don't appreciate you stealing other people's stories."<<< Even if a more subdued scene had been feasible for the Lois of Neverending Battle fame, all we'd get really is an apology from her, and it still ices out Jimmy's part. I think the show handled it well and with good humor, and Lois knew she had it coming and learned a lesson about underestimating Clark Kent when he's the victim of story stealing ;) In fairness though, if you want to rewrite NB, that's okay, as long as I get to rewrite IGACOY ;) >>>Well, we know where to go to find out what CK's idle fantasies are... ;)<<< Are these sexual or non-sexual? ;) Zoomway@aol.com (what the heck, it's 4:00a.m., the gutter's open ;) ========================================================================= Date: Mon, 22 Sep 1997 05:44:03 -0400 Reply-To: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" Sender: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" From: The Zoomway Subject: Re: Ideas In a message dated 97-09-22 01:40:42 EDT, demona@WIZNET.CA writes: << Nor will she write fic that I've been bugging her to write for months LOL >> Demi, did Rachel put you up to this? Or "Penny Irksome" as I like to call her ;) I am working on that sequel you wanted to Cyber Link, Penny's undercover story (and that Seinfeld script ;) that nfic we're collaberating on (remember that one? ;) and a story just for me :P Zoomway@aol.com (and that writing stuff I do for money. I love a panicky network season, it's good for business ;) ========================================================================= Date: Mon, 22 Sep 1997 11:16:46 -0400 Reply-To: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" Sender: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" From: Kathy Brown Subject: Re: Reading (was Ideas) In-Reply-To: <970922011200_1730482812@emout08.mail.aol.com> Mime-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset="us-ascii" At 1:12 AM -0400 9/22/97, The Zoomway wrote: > I think that's what I'd be >interested in hearing on the fanfic list. What do the readers and writers >read when they get an honest-to-goodness published novel? > Anyway, I'd really be interested in favorite novels, authors, genres, etc. LOL! You mean other FoLCs have time to ... gasp ... read??? Let's see, what do I read? Fanfic, List mail, Fanfic list mail ;) ... sense a theme? I read some magazines and the newspaper, but I can't remember the last time I picked up a book ... this is kind of embarassing. Oh! I just remembered. The last book I read was the Cherryh novel. ;) Kathy (actually, I read several books a day. They just have characters like Corduroy or Clifford as the protagonists or are written by Dr. Suess. ) ______________________ Kathy Brown kbrown@toolcity.net KathyB on IRC ______________________ ========================================================================= Date: Mon, 22 Sep 1997 11:50:52 -0400 Reply-To: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" Sender: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" From: Gary Subject: Re: Reading (was Ideas) In-Reply-To: MIME-version: 1.0 Content-type: text/plain; charset="us-ascii" At 11:16 AM 9/22/97 -0400, Kathy Brown wrote: >At 1:12 AM -0400 9/22/97, The Zoomway wrote: > >> I think that's what I'd be >>interested in hearing on the fanfic list. What do the readers and writers >>read when they get an honest-to-goodness published novel? >> Anyway, I'd really be interested in favorite novels, authors, genres, etc. > > >LOL! You mean other FoLCs have time to ... gasp ... read??? > >Let's see, what do I read? Fanfic, List mail, Fanfic list mail ;) ... >sense a theme? > > I'm reading "The NEW Male Sexuality - The Truth About Men, Sex, and Pleasure" by Bernie Zilbergeld, Ph.D. Author of Male Sexuality. And if you ask real nice I'll send the title of Chapter 2 to Debby for the nfic list... ;) P.S. Of course, technically, it is just nfic research... P.P.S. I need a hug! I never had a teddy bear, but I did have a Super Grover! =-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-= | Gary A. Rudick mailto:gar8434@rit.edu | | "You decide what you feel heaven is worth" - Deborah Gibson, TWYH | =-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-= ========================================================================= Date: Mon, 22 Sep 1997 13:21:50 -0400 Reply-To: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" Sender: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" Comments: RFC822 error: Incorrect or incomplete address field found and ignored. From: Pam Jernigan Subject: Re: Ideas MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable Content-Type: text/plain; charset=ISO-8859-1 Kathy wrote: >> Like the WHAM is OK as long as we get a satisfying WAFF at the end. <= < Or as Peace might put it, we don't mind the hurt as long as there's plent= y of comfort It also tends to be true that the bigger the WHAM, the bigger the WAFF, but it's not guaranteed. Anyway, in general, I think that it's not the idea that matters so much a= s the application of that idea. You can take one basic idea (Lois finds ou= t CK=3DSM) and create infinite variations on that theme... there are good a= nd bad revelation stories, but you can't say that the authors ripped each other off. I know I've written different takes on the same idea, and I don't *think* the resulting stories are repetitive. PJ !^NavFont02F02310018MGHHGSMGUHG42MG44HGD9HIy0631 E-mail from: Pam Jernigan, 22-Sep-1997 jernigan@compuserve.com / ChiefPam on the IRC ~~~~~ Unreformed, unrepentent, sometimes unproductive but never uninteresting fanfic writer = Visit Sarah & Pam's Shrine o'Fanfic at: http://www.geocities.com/hollywood/2501 ~~~~~ Lois and Clark Season 5 Fanfic: http://www.fortunecity.com/tattooine/mothership/60/season5.htm ~~~~~ "The first thing she said to me was 'Herbie, get me to the Planet.' Naturally, I wondered which planet..." ========================================================================= Date: Mon, 22 Sep 1997 12:50:10 -0500 Reply-To: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" Sender: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" From: Adrienne Perez Subject: Re: Ideas In-Reply-To: <970922011200_1730482812@emout08.mail.aol.com> Mime-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset="us-ascii" At 01:12 AM 9/22/97 -0400, you wrote: (Zoomway) >In a message dated 97-09-21 19:38:08 EDT, jernigan@COMPUSERVE.COM writes: > Most of the >fiction I read, as you can probably tell, is science fiction and some >fantasy. I have never read a romance novel of any type, or a western, or a >James Bond type of intrigue/adventure novel. I think that's what I'd be >interested in hearing on the fanfic list. What do the readers and writers >read when they get an honest-to-goodness published novel? I'm curious truly >because I remember in high school our English class had the choice of >Fahrenheit 451, A Separate Peace and To Kill a Mocking Bird. I was the only >female in the class to choose Fahrenheit 451 so I begin to wonder if I'm an >anomaly among others of my gender Anyway, I'd really be interested in >favorite novels, authors, genres, etc. > >Zoomway@aol.com Great question! I read novels to escape and relax so I really don't want to work too hard . So, artsy and highly stylized books don't do it for me. Neither do books with a lot of made up words or written in a dialect (I hated the Hobbitt and couldn't even finish The Lord of the Rings) Instead I like books rich in character and setting. To Kill a Mocking Bird is one of my favorites. I read very little science fiction but for some reason I've become attached to the Star Wars Books. I'm almost embarassed to buy them :). I love to read books that are set in an industry or culture I'm not familiar with. As a kid I used to like Arthur Hailey's books like Airport or Wheels. Chaim Potok's books describing Orthodox and Hasidic cultures and characters are long time favorites. When I find an author I like I tend to get "stuck" and then compulsively hunt down and read most of the author's works. In the last couple of years I've read most of the Jonathan Kellerman's Alex Delaware Murder Mysteries. My favorite author is Madeleine L'Engle. I have literally been reading and re-reading her books since childhood. She writes children's and adult fiction...nonfiction too. Her best known children's book is a Winkle in Time which is part one of a time travel trilogy. BTW anyone really into time travel should read "Time and Again" by Jack Finney. No complicated machines, just mind power. Well, this is most likely more information than you all wanted to know about me Fun question, Zoom! Adrienne perezas@xtrabox.com ========================================================================= Date: Mon, 22 Sep 1997 13:40:39 -0400 Reply-To: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" Sender: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" From: Barbara Garonzik Subject: Re: Reading (was Ideas) In a message dated 97-09-22 11:49:39 EDT, gar8434@RITVAX.ISC.RIT.EDU writes: << I'm reading "The NEW Male Sexuality - The Truth About Men, Sex, and Pleasure" by Bernie Zilbergeld, Ph.D. Author of Male Sexuality. >> I'm not reading anything so cerebral. Just finished Shirley Busbee's novel "A Heart for the Taking." Loved it. Barb ========================================================================= Date: Mon, 22 Sep 1997 12:48:47 CST Reply-To: jonesk@ur.msstate.edu Sender: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" From: Kay Fike Jones Organization: Mississippi State University Subject: Re: Reading (was Ideas) In-Reply-To: <970922133933_420075585@emout07.mail.aol.com> Not much time for reading books anymore, but I did manage to fit one in about a month ago. It was a Tony Hillerman mystery. Can't remember the name of the specific book but his are always good. Kay II ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Kay Fike Jones jonesk@ur.msstate.edu News Writer Mississippi State University, USA ========================================================================= Date: Mon, 22 Sep 1997 15:14:19 -0400 Reply-To: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" Sender: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" From: Laurie Stroh Subject: Re: Reading (was Ideas) In a message dated 97-09-22 11:15:34 EDT, you write: << Kathy (actually, I read several books a day. They just have characters like Corduroy or Clifford as the protagonists or are written by Dr. Suess. ) LOL Kathy we must lead the same life.....other than L&C fanfic and the listserv (both of them) and the WB and ABC L&C boards(I'm on AOL) and an occasional newspaper or magazine (like USA TODAY or People or Country Weekly) the only books I get to read are geared for rugrats. Last night it was "The Grinch Who Stole Christmas"...don't ask me I didn't pick it. I did actually read a real book last week and bragged to my hubby that I read a book that had absolutely nothing to do with Lois and Clark...."See honey, I do have a life!" But you know what? The book was OK and all but I have read fanfic that was tons better and I had a very hard time not thinking of Lois and Clark while reading the book. I kept picturing Teri and Dean as the protaganists......I guess I'm just spoiled!! Laurie LStroh1856@aol.com ========================================================================= Date: Mon, 22 Sep 1997 15:46:02 -0400 Reply-To: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" Sender: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" From: Laurie Stroh Subject: Reading In a message dated 97-09-22 01:12:43 EDT, Zoomway writes: << What do the readers and writers read when they get an honest-to-goodness published novel? I'm curious truly because I remember in high school our English class had the choice of Fahrenheit 451, A Separate Peace and To Kill a Mocking Bird. I was the only female in the class to choose Fahrenheit 451 so I begin to wonder if I'm an anomaly among others of my gender Anyway, I'd really be interested in favorite novels, authors, genres, etc. >> It's funny that you should mention "To Kill a Mockingbird" for that is one of my all time favorite books......if you've never taken the time to read it you should. It's not very long but oh so good and much better than the movie (which I enjoyed as well). Another favorite book of mine was "The Thorn Birds" even though she did spend a lot of time describing the Australian landscape....... Since going online last year and hooking up with all you wonderful *folcs* my reading of actual published material has dwindled to about nil.........but authors that I have enjoyed reading include Michael Palmer (he writes medical thrillers), John Grisham (if you don't know who he is you're really out of it), Judith Michael (a husband-wife writing team that write contemporary romance type novels) and Janet Daily (prior to discovering she is a plagerist!). To the person on the list that mentioned the children's book "A Wrinkle in Time" I just want to say that that was one of my favorite books as a kid......one that not a lot of people seemed to have read but one that I will always remember. Laurie LStroh1856@aol.com ========================================================================= Date: Mon, 22 Sep 1997 13:42:02 -0700 Reply-To: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" Sender: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" From: Sara Kraft Subject: Re: Reading (was Ideas) Mime-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset="us-ascii" >At 1:12 AM -0400 9/22/97, The Zoomway wrote: > >> I think that's what I'd be >>interested in hearing on the fanfic list. What do the readers and writers >>read when they get an honest-to-goodness published novel? >> Anyway, I'd really be interested in favorite novels, authors, genres, etc. Before I discovered fanfic, I liked (and still do, just don't have the time to read) reading Dean Koontz novels (horror/suspense). Now I read fanfic, fanfic and well...fanfic. But actually, I did pick up the Roger Stern novel "The Death and Life of Superman" and have started reading it. (I didn't realize at the time but I was wearing my 'S' shirt when I bought it. No wonder I got funny looks. Doh!). >LOL! You mean other FoLCs have time to ... gasp ... read??? No, not really. =) >Let's see, what do I read? Fanfic, List mail, Fanfic list mail ;) ... >sense a theme? Exactly! >Oh! I just remembered. The last book I read was the Cherryh novel. ;) I liked that one. That's one of the last books I read too. Unless you count school mandated reading. =p Sara Kraft (tmax@azstarnet.com) ========================================================================= Date: Mon, 22 Sep 1997 16:31:09 -0400 Reply-To: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" Sender: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" From: Gary Subject: Re: Reading (was Ideas) In-Reply-To: <3.0.1.16.19970922115052.4a8f576c@vmspop.isc.rit.edu> MIME-version: 1.0 Content-type: text/plain; charset="us-ascii" >>At 1:12 AM -0400 9/22/97, The Zoomway wrote: >> >>> I think that's what I'd be >>>interested in hearing on the fanfic list. What do the readers and writers >>>read when they get an honest-to-goodness published novel? >>> Anyway, I'd really be interested in favorite novels, authors, genres, etc. >> Okay, my all-time favorite is The Count of Monte Cristo by Dumas, Alexandre, 1802-1870 The Count of Monte Cristo or the adventures of Edmond Dantes, which was so much better than Tale of Two Cities...anyone else read both? (Both are historical novels set against the backdrop of the French Revolution - i.e. "Let them eat cake.") =-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-= | Gary A. Rudick mailto:gar8434@rit.edu | | "You decide what you feel heaven is worth" - Deborah Gibson, TWYH | =-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-= ========================================================================= Date: Tue, 23 Sep 1997 06:59:47 +1000 Reply-To: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" Sender: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" From: Jenny Stosser Subject: Reading (was Re: Ideas) In-Reply-To: <970922011200_1730482812@emout08.mail.aol.com> Mime-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset="us-ascii" At 01:12 AM 22/09/97 -0400, Zoomway wrote: > There is some fanfic that would make a horrible episode for the >series, but is still great to read. My sister in law, who is NOT a reader of anything much except the Tabloid magazines (makes me wonder why I buy my own Woman's Day each week, sometimes) just finished reading my L&C fanfic and wanted everyone here to know that she thinks I should submit it to TNT as the basis for the telemovie that they should make of it one day. My mother also thinks I should submit it to Warner Bros, or DC Comics. But she hasn't read it. I think the last thing my mother read was the newspaper. (/me wonders why she is related to so many non-readers, when she has at least two walls full of books which she will read over and over again, as well as two filing cabinets full of comics!) >It's like Stranger in a Strange Land. I >think that would make a gosh awful movie, too much is in your head, but it's >a mesmerizing novel to read if you like that kind of story. Zoom, this is weird. I love almost everything Heinlein's written, but I couldn't stand SIASL when I first read it about 15 years ago. My favourite by him would have to be Time Enough For Love, I think. >Most of the fiction I read, as you can probably tell, is science fiction and some >fantasy. I have never read a romance novel of any type, or a western, or a >James Bond type of intrigue/adventure novel. I think that's what I'd be >interested in hearing on the fanfic list. What do the readers and writers >read when they get an honest-to-goodness published novel? I tend to stay within the SF/Fantasy range when I'm reading books most of the time too. The *first* fantasy book I read was called The Broken Sword, and it was by Poul Anderson. I don't remember a thing about it, but I remember Dad choosing it out of his bookcase as one I was old enough to enjoy when I was twelve. I get the impression I'd been bugging him to let me read one of his books for a while before that. Oh, and before that, my all-time favourite books were the Krunkles of Narnia (I couldn't say Chronicles at the time). I still pull them out and reread them on occasion. At the moment I'm working my way through Anne McCaffrey's Pern books again (in no particular order). In recent weeks I've read DragonFlight, DragonQuest DragonsDawn, and now I'm halfway through Red Star Rising (released in the US as DragonsEye, I believe). These are probably my favourite books of all time these days (am I allowed to change my choice when I say "of all time?" ) - some years ago, I had 15 books signed by the author, and now I'm debating whether I should replace my copy of Dragonquest, which is literally falling apart at the seams! Other authors I enjoy include Misty Lackey (in particular her Valdemar series), Melanie Rawn, Katherine Kerr, David Eddings... hmmm, I've just noticed that most of my favourite authors tend to write in series! I wonder why that is? I also enjoy Isaac Asimov's junior adult stuff, Robert Silverberg's time travel stories, Oh, and when my parents moved out of the house I grew up in to a smaller place, I inherited Dad's collection of Analog magazines, which at the time was an almost complete run going back to December 1959. I managed to fill in the missing pieces via the Internet, so it now IS a complete collection. One day I might even get to sit down and read them all! Oh, yeah, I also collect comics. Have done since at least 1978 (that's the cover date on the first DC Comic I ever bought, but before that I was buying Australian black and white reprints with no date inside them), and as I said before I have two filing cabinets full of them now. I also read Woman's Day almost every week, and pick up the occasional other tabloid magazine. It's a nasty habit, but it's one of the few vices I have that actually costs money, so who cares!? I'm curious truly >because I remember in high school our English class had the choice of >Fahrenheit 451, A Separate Peace and To Kill a Mocking Bird. I was the only >female in the class to choose Fahrenheit 451 so I begin to wonder if I'm an >anomaly among others of my gender Anyway, I'd really be interested in >favorite novels, authors, genres, etc. I would have chosen the Bradbury book too, but only cos I've seen the movie of TKAMB and I've never heard of ASP. Oh yeah, Kathy mentioned that she reads a lot of Dr Seuss... I read quite a bit of the same "Ernie's BedTime story" and "Thomas and the... by Buzz Books". David has been helping me to get through the really hard words in those ones -- Jenny Stosser -*- jenerate@ozramp.net.au -*- (Jenerator or MoiAussie on IRC) This message is umop ap!sdn -*- David is 5 and Megan is 2! Photos on the web-page! Visit the Stosser Family HomePage: http://www.ozramp.net.au/~jenerate ========================================================================= Date: Mon, 22 Sep 1997 23:14:32 +0000 Reply-To: dom-mel@dial.pipex.com Sender: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" Comments: Authenticated sender is From: Dom Melaragni Subject: Re: Reading (was Re: Ideas) In-Reply-To: <3.0.1.32.19970923065947.0069d944@mail.ozramp.net.au> MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-type: text/plain; charset=US-ASCII Content-transfer-encoding: 7BIT I read way too much......at least I used to.......for a while though I read a lot more fanfic than ordinary books. Now that I'm commuting again though, I've started picking up a lot of books again. I tend to read just about everything.......the author I have most of is Anne McCaffrey and probably Asimov but I hadn't read many of them in a while....... Favourite things lately have been Bill Bryson's Made in America and Tales of a Small Island and my current book, Maupins Tales from the City. And of course, who could forget the *fascinating* book I bought in Seattle and left there......had to buy another one to find out waht happened......Nadia the werewolf with interesting tendencies.....the UKers took to reading it as a bedtime story There was lots of barbaric longing Dom (wondering what to take off her shelf next ......or whether to look in the box of the last 3 year's comics......I did like that SUperman/WonderWOman....Whom Gods Destroy series) ================================================================= Dom Melaragni (FlakeyDom) The LnC drinking game and Fest pics http://ds.dial.pipex.com/dom-mel/index.htm ?8-)] Clark Kent smiley with the superhero squarejaw chin ========================================================================= Date: Mon, 22 Sep 1997 20:46:04 -0400 Reply-To: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" Sender: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" From: "Georgia E. Walden" Subject: Re: Reading In a message dated 97-09-22 15:48:37 EDT, Laurie writes: << Since going online last year and hooking up with all you wonderful *folcs* my reading of actual published material has dwindled to about nil.... >> Whew - that's a relief. I thought I was the only one who had become a non-reader since getting involved with online fandom. My job requires I keep up with the rugrat literature (elementary school librarian) but for myself, there's nothing that interests me quite as much as Lois and Clark. I read for pleasure and right now, I get more pleasure from the various mailing lists than anything else. Before, though, I read constantly and skipped around: science fiction, fantasy, romance both historical and contemporary, mysteries, and the occasional thriller. I also like non-fiction - politics, linguistics, science, popular culture. I once read A HIstory of Warfare by John Keegan back to back with Desire by Amanda Quick and enjoyed them both. My most recent "real" book was A Writer's Journey by Christopher Vogler. It was recommended by someone on LOISCLA. ;) Georgia (guess I'd better try to track down Rag and Bone - I'm not an Anne Rice fan, but there are extenuating circumstances...) ========================================================================= Date: Mon, 22 Sep 1997 22:43:56 -0400 Reply-To: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" Sender: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" Comments: RFC822 error: Incorrect or incomplete address field found and ignored. From: Pam Jernigan Subject: Reading (was Ideas) MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable Content-Type: text/plain; charset=ISO-8859-1 re: "Joe's Story", Zoomway wrote: >> I don't regret writing it even though it made some readers uncomfortable (okay, with Leigh I got a 14 page scolding ;) << So when Leigh only sent 5 pages worth of complaints over "Going to the Chapel", does that mean she liked it? >> Most of the fiction I read, as you can probably tell, is science fiction and some fantasy. I have never read a romance novel of any type, = or a western, or a James Bond type of intrigue/adventure novel. ...I begin to wonder if I'm an anomaly among others of my gender Anyway, I'd really be interested in favorite novels, authors, genres, etc. << Okay, you asked for it... my favorite genre is science fiction; favorite authors include Isaac Asimov, Anne McCaffrey and Lois McMaster Bujold (I *highly* recommend her to anyone who'll stand still). I'm quit= e fond of most of Tom Clancy's novels. I like selected books by Heinlein and Niven/Pournelle. I think H. Beam Piper is chronically underappreciated. Terry Pratchett writes hysterically funny fantasy book= s (Discworld). I've also long suspected that I was an atypical female = and one of the ways I knew I should marry my husband was the large overla= p in our libraries. I like some mysteries, mostly by Dorothy Sayers (Lord Peter Wimsey); I te= nd to go for historical settings there, and I like an element of romance and/or humor in the story, with a minimum of gore However... I confess, I also read romances, of several types. I started reading Regency romances (a popular subgenre set in England, mostly, in the early 1800s), especially those written by Georgette Heyer = in high school (G.H. is the classic author of regencies; her stories have no= sex but lots of humor and great characterization). A little later, after= my heart was first broken ( ) I read romances voraciously just t= o have something to fill the time, and since I could easily read three of them in a day, I wasn't too picky about quality. I still read them occasionally, when I can find time; they're fun (as long as I don't stumb= le into the ones that make me want to take the "heroine" out behind somethin= g and thrash her for idiotic behavior ). For these, I tend to read the "series" romance novels - they've got modern settings, and they're not to= o long. The thicker, historical romances tend to frustrate me too much - in= order to fill their page count, the author has to keep putting up artificial barriers between her protagonists - Maysons and Scardinos, and= Lex and Deter and worse... (But they're not usually as bad as Debby was in Dawning6 with WWW Waldecker popping up at the *worst* time!) I think that mostly covers it... PJ !^NavFont02F089C0023MGHHGeMGgHG81MG83HGDEMGE0HIHMIJHO9EA721 E-mail from: Pam Jernigan, 22-Sep-1997 jernigan@compuserve.com / ChiefPam on the IRC ~~~~~ Unreformed, unrepentent, sometimes unproductive but never uninteresting fanfic writer = Visit Sarah & Pam's Shrine o'Fanfic at: http://www.geocities.com/hollywood/2501 ~~~~~ Lois and Clark Season 5 Fanfic: http://www.fortunecity.com/tattooine/mothership/60/season5.htm ~~~~~ "The first thing she said to me was 'Herbie, get me to the Planet.' Naturally, I wondered which planet..." ========================================================================= Date: Mon, 22 Sep 1997 23:00:04 -0400 Reply-To: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" Sender: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" From: Barbara Garonzik Subject: Re: Reading In a message dated 97-09-22 15:48:37 EDT, you write: << Janet Daily (prior to discovering she is a plagerist!). >> I didn't know this. Was she actually charged? barb ========================================================================= Date: Tue, 23 Sep 1997 00:09:37 -0400 Reply-To: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" Sender: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" Comments: RFC822 error: Incorrect or incomplete address field found and ignored. From: Pam Jernigan Subject: Re: Reading (was Ideas) MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable Content-Type: text/plain; charset=ISO-8859-1 >> Okay, my all-time favorite is The Count of Monte Cristo by Dumas, Alexandre, 1802-1870 The Count of Monte Cristo or the adventures of Edmond Dantes, which was so much better than Tale of Two Cities...anyone else read both?= (Both are historical novels set against the backdrop of the French Revolution - i.e. "Let them eat cake.") << I may have read them at some point - I vaguely remember doing A Tale of Two Cities in school - but for that time period I much prefer The Scarlet Pimpernel - a dashing hero who disguises himself as an ordinary man... a woman who loves the hero, but is married to the man - sound familiar? PJ "They seek him here, they seek him there..." !^NavFont02F0227000CMGJHH\MH^HIoBC15 ========================================================================= Date: Tue, 23 Sep 1997 13:46:57 -0400 Reply-To: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" Sender: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" From: Angela Garmaise Subject: Re: Fav books In-Reply-To: <3.0.1.16.19970922163109.4b373872@vmspop.isc.rit.edu> Mime-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: TEXT/PLAIN; charset=US-ASCII I have to say that when it comes to classics, Les Miserable (the slightly shortened version) is my all time fav (Victor Hugo). When it comes to slightly more modern stuff.... don't get me started. I'm a vociferous reader, and will read absolutely anything I can get my hands on, especially during school holidays! Angie G. ========================================================================= Date: Tue, 23 Sep 1997 14:09:38 -0400 Reply-To: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" Sender: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" From: Peace Everett Subject: Re: Reading Um, did someone mention Anne Rice? This came in today's PEOPLE email newsletter: PEOPLE ONLINE DAILY TUESDAY, SEPTEMBER 23, 1997 RAISING CAIN Even though his "Lois & Clark: The New Adventures of Superman" cape has been retired, Dean Cain is not quite ready to let his feet touch the ground. Variety reports that the ex-Man of Steel has signed a deal to star in author Anne Rice's first original TV project, a pilot for CBS called "Rag & Bone." IN this supernatural drama, Caine will star as a former priest, now New Orleans cop, who encounters the ghost of a cop from the 1950s. Peace Come read my fanfic! and link to Season 5 - The Adventures Continue... A FoLC Named Peace - http://members.aol.com/PEverett9/peace.html Kal-El: "My heart is waiting for me back on Earth. Lois is my heart. I was an outsider there.. incomplete.. until I met her." ========================================================================= Date: Tue, 23 Sep 1997 15:06:16 -0400 Reply-To: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" Sender: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" From: Laurie Stroh Subject: Re: Reading In a message dated 97-09-22 23:02:48 EDT, you write: << << Janet Daily (prior to discovering she is a plagerist!). >> I didn't know this. Was she actually charged? barb >> Well....she was discovered via the internet during some sort of romance readers/writers chat. She has admitted that she plagerized part of two of Nora Roberts books and Nora is not sure what she is going to do about it......there was a a short article in People Weekly a couple of months ago that talked about the whole thing. If you're interested I'm sure you could get a copy of the article from your library. Laurie ========================================================================= Date: Tue, 23 Sep 1997 15:10:08 -0400 Reply-To: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" Sender: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" From: Laurie Stroh Subject: Re: Reading In a message dated 97-09-23 00:43:46 EDT, you write: << Georgia (guess I'd better try to track down Rag and Bone - I'm not an Anne Rice fan, but there are extenuating circumstances...) >> I am not real familiar with Anne Rice's stuff but I was under the impression that Rag and Bone was not a book of hers but rather something she helped develop specifically for television. Perhaps someone on the list who knows more about her work could clue us in on this. Laurie LStroh1856@aol.com ========================================================================= Date: Tue, 23 Sep 1997 16:35:24 -0500 Reply-To: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" Sender: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" From: Genevieve Subject: Re: Ideas Comments: cc: smacy@innercite.com Mime-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset="us-ascii" >I personally don't think I have a problem with almost any type of fanfic >(other than the cheating or death fic type) I like funny stuff, romantic >stuff, and stuff that has a surprise or a twist to it. This lead to an interesting discussion of Ruth's "A Winter Tale," (which I vaguely remember) "Puzzles" (which I don't remember at all), Gary's sequel (which I also don't remember -- I'll have to take a trip to the archives and refresh my memory), and "Molly", which I do remember, and I have to agree with whoever said it was totally implausible. The general consensus seemed to be, however, that cheating, deaths and divorces left a sour taste in many people's mouths. I'll speak up for the minority here, and say that *I'd* enjoy reading cheating or death fic types, assuming, of course that they are well done. I don't read for the WAFFs, particularly -- in fact, (dare I say it?) I find WAFFs kind of boring, especially WAFFs without WHAMs preceeding them. What I tend to look for is different takes on the characters, how they react in certain [WHAMmy] situations. Divorce, cheating, death -- they would all put our favorite characters under a lot of stress, and different aspects of their characters. What could cause Lois or Clark to think of divorce or cheating? And interesting questions, and I do think there are things that could. (I remember when I read "Molly" that that was the end of that marriage -- that Lois would never forgive him that.) I think there are a lot of aspects in both their characters which will not make marriage easy for them. It'll not be a bed of roses for either of them -- at least not if we take off our rose-coloured glasses of the perfect couple with the super-natural "bond." And it won't be clones, dishonest doctors, New Kryptonians, murder charges or time windows that cause problems in their marriage, but some of the character traits of Lois and Clark themselves. A death story is the end of Lois and Clark, but, while death is always the end of *someone's* story, everyone elses's stories continue. How the survivor copes, remembers, can make for interesting reading. I read Beauty and the Beast fanfic, and I much prefer the fanfic set after Catherine's death, to the "classic" stories. Perhaps, however, that's just because the ending to that series was so unsatisfactory. There's been very little fanfic written about one of the more interesting parts of the legend to me -- Superman's refusal to kill. How high a price will he pay the keep his hands clean, what would push him accross that line? How would he react after he killed someone, and how would Lois react? Would she blame him, comfort him, try to justify it in his eyes? One of the things that has surprised me is that in our ever-growing mountain of fanfic dealing with Alt-Clark, almost all of it, if not all of it, choose the WAFFy way, pairing him up with Alt-Lois or Clone Lois. Zoomway's latest even gave him back his secret identity with a seeing eye dog. No one has really examined what Superman would be like in the Alt-Universe. I have visions of a lonely Clark, living in a secure penthouse (sort of like Luthor's), putting communication satellites into orbit for the Rudolph Murdoch's of the world for a significant sum, and agonizing over whether to sign a contract with the Defense Department. Now it could be argued that those types of stories are not "Lois and Clark" fanfic, but just plain "Clark" fanfic, and perhaps they are. They don't lend themselves to WAFFs easily, that's for sure. But they could explore some unexplored areas. Peace said: >one of the first lines was "It was a year since the >divorce" or words to that effect. Well, I closed the file right then and >went to work *very* depressed -- just that thought really tore me up (who >me? too involved? nah... ;) A story that starts out talking about a divorce seems very optimistic to me, as you have the whole story left for the reconciliation. (WAFF, WAFF, WAFF!) Stories that *end* with the divorce are the depressing ones. Although occasionally, as with Rhett and Scarlett, one can only say "it's about time!" when the marriage *finally* breaks up. ======================================================================= Genevieve (NightSky@erols.com) "Do you suppose they celebrate death days on the other side? Will the day we give up the ghost be a day of celebration in heaven, or are we just another log on the fires of hell?"--The Nightcrawler (Forever Knight) ========================================================================= Date: Tue, 23 Sep 1997 16:36:18 -0500 Reply-To: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" Sender: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" From: Genevieve Subject: Re: Reading (was Re: Ideas) Mime-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset="us-ascii" Zoomway asked: > Anyway, I'd really be interested in favorite novels, authors, genres, etc. The replies have been fascinating; more proof that we are all "kindred spirits" in a way. A lot of you have mentioned books that I, too, would put on my "favorite books" list. For a quick read, I'll grab published "fanfic" -- the Star Trek, Star Wars, Quantum Leap or Forever Knight novels. Outside of fanfic, I still tend to read series books -- Science fiction/fantasy (MacCaffery, Marion Zimmer Bradley), or mysteries. I like to see the same detective over and over again, but changing -- finding romance, growing older and wiser. Dorothy Sayers has been mentioned, and I've been enjoying Elizabeth George's mysteries these last few years. And I'll read anything (no matter how bad) about King Arthur or Robin Hood. I like realistic novels that come in series too. Jane Duncan's "My Friends" series is one of my favorites, and I'm haunting used bookshops looking for them. The libraries are getting rid of them, and they are very hard to find right now. Someone mentioned Madeline L'Engle's novels. I love those as well. They too fit in the category of "series" books in many ways, since a major character in one will show up as a minor character in another. There is always a chance to find out something new about a wonderful character. Although I've always been disappointed that we found out what happened to Susy Austin in "A Severed Wasp", but there was not a clue about Vicky. Jenny, I grew up on my father's Analog/Astounding collection as well--his went back to 1946. It was fun comparing the serialized version in Astounding of "Dragonflight", "Citizen of the Galazy" or "Dune" for instance, with what finally was published. Lots of minor, but telling, changes. Sadly, my sister got the magazines when my mother sold the house. I've read all of Heinlein's novels, and enjoyed them. I love re-reading the juvenile novels he wrote in the 1950s. I agree that Stranger in a Strange Land was the beginning of his "weird" stage; my candidate for "best" Heinlein novel is "The Moon is a Harsh Mistress". I've always tended to go off the deep end over books; this obsession with Lois and Clark is nothing new--it's just the first time I've had anyone to share an obsession with. When I was 13 I read a copy of Frank Herbert's "Dune" to shreads; I think it was the only book I read for the entire year. Likewise in later years I wore out Elysyth Thane's "Williamsburg novels", the Lord of the Rings, Katherine Kurtz Deryni novels, and Atlas Shrugged. I'd write my own "mental fanfic" around these stories, the same way I do LNC. I don't read many romances anymore, and can't remember the last time I picked up a "bodice-ripper." But my all-time favorite book, which has kept that status for over 20 years now, is Jane Austen's Pride and Prejudice. This is a wonderful romance, but also about secrets, disguises (well, misleading public images, anyway) and self-discovery. I must re-read the whole thing at least two or three times a year. -------------------------------------------------------------------------- Genevieve (NightSky@erols.com) ; To find out anything you want to know about Superman (in comics, cartoons, television, or movies, from Bud Collyer to Dean Cain) -- check out THE SUPERMAN HOMEPAGE ========================================================================= Date: Tue, 23 Sep 1997 17:52:04 -0400 Reply-To: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" Sender: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" From: Becky Lewis Subject: Re: Reading MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=unknown-8bit Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit >From Georgia's post In a message dated 97-09-23 00:43:46 EDT, you write: >> Since going online last year and hooking up with all you wonderful *folcs* >> my reading of actual published material has dwindled to about nil.... >> > > Whew - that's a relief. I thought I was the only one who had become a > non-reader since getting involved with online fandom. Me, too, it's nice to know I'm not alone > > Before, though, I read constantly and skipped around: science fiction, > fantasy, romance both historical and contemporary, mysteries, and the > occasional thriller. > That sounds like me as well, as did the person who posted she tends to follow the works of an author she likes until she’s read them all. Personally, I found the timing of this question quite ironic, because I realized over the weekend that it had been months since I'd read a "real" book, so I put the library and the secondhand bookstore on my errand list. The library visit yielded two Star Trek novels and a novel by Mary Stewart of the “Crystal Cave” fame called “The Prince and the Pilgrim.” The used bookstore netted three of Lillian Jackson Braun’s “The Cat Who...” mysteries. Definitely a pattern...and by the way, I would have picked Fahrenheit 451, given the same choice! Becky blewispar3@aol.com ========================================================================= Date: Tue, 23 Sep 1997 18:23:44 -0400 Reply-To: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" Sender: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" From: "Georgia E. Walden" Subject: Re: Reading In a message dated 97-09-23 15:12:22 EDT, you write: << am not real familiar with Anne Rice's stuff but I was under the impression that Rag and Bone was not a book of hers but rather something she helped develop specifically for television. Perhaps someone on the list who knows more about her work could clue us in on this. >> You're absolutely right, Laurie, as I would have known if I'd been reading every post instead of just skimming. ;) However, if the show does make it to air, I'll bet there'll be a TV tie-in paperback - the Anne Rice name is too salable for them to miss the opportunity. And usually those things have *pictures* (yeah, I'm shallow ) Georgia ========================================================================= Date: Tue, 23 Sep 1997 20:49:45 -0400 Reply-To: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" Sender: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" From: Susan E VanCott Subject: A fanfic idea Well, it's been a couple days since I saw Honeymoon in Metropolis again, and I had a kind of a thought. Did anyone else notice the similarities between HIM and Superman 2? L&C have to go undercover as a married couple in a honeymoon suite. The bellboy makes cracks at them. Okay, maybe there aren't THAT many similarites, but the big one is there: L&C being an undercover married couple at a honeymoon suite. I think it would be awesome to combine the movie and the ep. There were parts of the movie that I just didn't like, such as "Don't you know this is killing me?" prompting CK to erase Lois' memory of his secret. ARGHH! And there were some stupid lines such as, "I don't know why I did that." "Maybe you wanted to." "I don't think I did." Sheesh. But I loved Lois jumping into a river because she thinks CK=S. And the brush line. "Where's my brush? Where's my brush? God, not only have I lost my mind, I've lost my brush!" And the bellboy saying "Have a happy...whatever." The movie had the potential to be so much better. And I think that Teri's Lois would react better than Margot's Lois. And I think I would have to use the whole ice palace Fortress of Solitude. Sorry, but L&C wouldn't fit in a treehouse! And I think that Dean's Clark could have beat up that creep in the diner even without powers, although that would lose the scene in the end that was so funny. I think it's an even trade, not to have to see CK get beat up. And I bet I could have a little fun with the kissing contest Lois mentions in Superman 2.... Does anybody have any ideas for the story? ********************************************************* "Lois, get a grip!" "Ooh, believe me, I'd love to!" ;) ~~>Susan<~~ ******************************************************** ========================================================================= Date: Tue, 23 Sep 1997 21:05:56 -0400 Reply-To: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" Sender: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" From: Susan E VanCott Subject: Comb post: Re: Reading, Ann Rice, and evil ABC The most recent book I finished was Oedipus Rex for school. I of course couldn't stop thinking of "Oedipus Wrecks"... Actually, I've decided that the title of that ep wasn't really appropriate. See, if you don't know already, and Oedipus complex is being in love with your mother. Herkimer Smith wasn't in love with his mother, he just felt ignored. Well, at least that was my interpretation. I guess that the title was somewhat appropriate, but not exactly. And about that Ann Rice Rag & Bone thing... I can't wait! Dean as a cop, I can see. A priest turned cop, though? That's kind of strange, but fine with me! It sounds like a cool series. I have been looking around for little insults at ABC and Disney. In one day I found two! A thing about television said something about ABC's "TV is good" campaign. It seems that they have an ad that says "You've got billions of brain cells" or something like that. This article in the paper pointed out the obvious evil in that statement. It's like saying "What's a couple brain cells down the tube?" Or, more appropriately, ABC is saying "TV is power. The power to lull, to pacify. And when all eyes are glazed and all minds are jelly, the power to take." Hmm, do you think that ABC is starting an evil conspiracy to take over people's minds? And then, later, I saw an interview with Jaleel White (the guy who plays Urkel on Family Matters). They asked him how he felt to move from ABC, the station that gave him his fame and fortune, to CBS. He said he was really happy to make the move. Hehehehe! ********************************************************* "Lois, get a grip!" "Ooh, believe me, I'd love to!" ~~>Susan<~~ ******************************************************** ========================================================================= Date: Tue, 23 Sep 1997 21:38:44 -0400 Reply-To: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" Sender: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" From: Beverly Latham Subject: Reading, Writing & 'Rithmetic . . . oops wrong group [was Re: Ideas] Mime-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset="us-ascii" At 01:12 AM 9/22/97 -0400, The Zoomway wrote: >I got positive and negative feedback on the story, but >this, from part of Leigh Raglan's 14 page scolding was the much more typical >response. "This is wrong! There is no way, shape or form that would cause >Clark Kent to live a lie and a sexual relationship with Lois Lane as >Superman!" Ummm . . . I do seem to remember this one, yet can't quite place it. And at the moment, I'm too lazy to dig out a post where someone mentions the title. Although it's entirely possible that I'm thinking of another story. There is quite a lot of fanfic out there I haven't read. I do seem to remember a story where Superman ends up in bed with Lois before telling her . . . the secret, not that they're in bed, hehehe . . . thought I might want to clear that up. I would hope Lois might figure out the other on her own . . . er, where was I? but I thought that story was by another author. If I remember correctly, the one I read bothered me a little but not nearly as much as a couple of others that had Clark doing things totally out of character with OTHERS besides Lois . . . which is probably the redeeming feature of the above situation, at least for me. If we truly want to push the envelop, I can see Clark being tempted beyond his ability to resist under the right circumstances as long as we're talking about Lois. >Or, >Becky had just bought some Superman bubble bath and said she'd like to have a >story involving a bubble bath, and so I wrote Dirty Bubbles. Some stopped >reading that short story after the first paragraph indicated Lois was married >to Lex Luthor This I can very much identify with because I caught some flack, gentle though it was, over a similar kind of situation in one of my stories . . . and Lois was married to CLARK the whole time! I just let the reader think otherwise and almost came to regret it before the dust settled. Whew! Funny how people do react to things so very differently. >Most of the >fiction I read, as you can probably tell, is science fiction and some >fantasy. I have never read a romance novel of any type, or a western, or a >James Bond type of intrigue/adventure novel. I think that's what I'd be >interested in hearing on the fanfic list. What do the readers and writers >read when they get an honest-to-goodness published novel? I have an entire paperback collection of Agatha Christie mysteries. I think I have everything of hers that's been published in America. Along with hers, I've read quite a few other mystery writers over the years, but I prefer whodunits to any other kinds of mysteries. I also have around fifty STAR TREK paperbacks, with most of those being THE NEXT GENERATION, but I stopped buying them around four years ago . . . hmmm, now why does that seem significant? I bought a few of the STAR WARS novels but became really disappointed in them, extremely fast. The first three by Zahn were great, but after that I did not like the way they were developing the lives of the principles. To that add assorted sci-fi and fantasy books and I do mean assorted. My tastes in that genre sort of skip around quite a lot and I don't generally go with the authors considered The Classics. For that matter, my tastes in fiction have skipped around my entire life. I even had a Louis L'Amour phase. Westerns, for those that don't know. However, the bulk of my personal library are romances and now I'm gonna do a little ranting, more or less. Notice I said romances, mind you, not bodice-rippers. Personally, if anyone's bodice is going to be ripped, I think it should be Clark's. He does it so very well. Seriously, though, I've run across true bodice-rippers in the past and they almost turned me off romances completely because they ARE disgusting. A true bodice-ripper is not about love but about domination. This does not equal romance in my book. I'm not saying they aren't still being published, but for the most part, that's not what's out there nowadays in the mainstream romance genre and hasn't been for, oh, at least the last ten years or so. What is available is incredible both in sheer volume and variety. I'm always amazed when someone says they've never read a romance before because any love story in any format is a romance. Louis L'Amour had a romance in almost every one of his westerns if I remember correctly. The difference in terms of genre style is that romance specializes in exploring the emotions of the pair of, um, combatants as they discover each other. Instead of focusing in on the action taking place in, say, a mystery or adventure story, the primary focus in a romance is in on what's going inside the hero and heroine's heads and hearts. The key word there is primary, though, because the best romances are filled with action and, contrary to popular belief, it's not all sex. Oh, there are love scenes, but notice the change in phrasing. Loves scenes are as much about emotions as they are the physical action of sex. Big distinction. And, yes, it is exactly this distinction that makes romances an acquired taste that has to be developed just like with any other form of literature. This distinction is also why some of the most memorable genre-true romance stories do not translate well to the visual medias of movies and televisions, it's just too difficult to adequately depict getting inside peoples heads and showing their emotions. It can be done and has been quite well on occassion, but a lot of what truly makes it a romance is lost in the process. Think of all the things that we bemoan never got discussed and dealt with on L&C and then think about how much a lot of them were internal to the characters in the first place. There are simply limits on how much can be dealt with emotionally outside of the written word. One of the things I find truly interesting about romance as a seperate and distinct genre from other forms of fiction literature is that because it's about the emotions involved between the pair, the outside plots can take place in just about any situation, in any locale, and in any time-frame. You name it, it could be a romance. Hence, there are mystery romances, suspense romances, action-adventure romances, gothic romances, fantasy romances, sci-fi romances, time-travel romances. And then there are the historicals . . . gads, anything from ancient civilizations to early twentieth century on any continent. My personal favorites there are the English medievals. Love those knights. Oh, and then there are the Scots. Would I like Clark in a kilt? Ya bet ya, I would. Or a loincloth . . . or a toga . . . or, hmmm, time for some more historical research . . . /\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\ Beverly Latham blatham@hop-uky.campus.mci.net \/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/\/ ========================================================================= Date: Tue, 23 Sep 1997 21:52:32 -0400 Reply-To: Kassia@concentric.net Sender: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" From: Kassia Subject: Re: Reading, Ann Rice, and evil ABC MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=us-ascii Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit Susan E VanCott wrote: > I of course couldn't stop thinking of "Oedipus Wrecks"... Actually, I've decided that the title of that ep wasn't really appropriate. Oedipus complex is being in love with your mother. Herkimer Smith wasn't in love with his mother, *I don't think that the title was the BEST that they could have come up with....so I would have to agree.... > > And about that Ann Rice Rag & Bone thing... I can't wait! Dean as a cop, I can see. A priest turned cop, though? That's kind of strange, but fine with me! It sounds like a cool series. It definitely sounds quite promising....though I, too, am a bit skeptical of imagining Dean as a former priest....I'm sure we'd all love to share some 'confessions' with our Man of Steel! :) Tanya "Old news isn't news--it's history" ========================================================================= Date: Tue, 23 Sep 1997 21:54:46 -0400 Reply-To: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" Sender: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" From: Gary Subject: Re: A fanfic idea In-Reply-To: <19970923.204945.3358.0.GutterFic@juno.com> MIME-version: 1.0 Content-type: text/plain; charset="us-ascii" Hmmmm....Let's see honeymoon suite, ice palace, diner fight, and Clark gets to squeeze Lois' oranges...sounds like a fanfic waiting to be written! At 08:49 PM 9/23/97 -0400, you wrote: >Well, it's been a couple days since I saw Honeymoon in Metropolis again, >and I had a kind of a thought. Did anyone else notice the similarities >between HIM and Superman 2? L&C have to go undercover as a married >couple in a honeymoon suite. The bellboy makes cracks at them. Okay, >maybe there aren't THAT many similarites, but the big one is there: L&C >being an undercover married couple at a honeymoon suite. I think it >would be awesome to combine the movie and the ep. There were parts of >the movie that I just didn't like, such as "Don't you know this is >killing me?" prompting CK to erase Lois' memory of his secret. ARGHH! >And there were some stupid lines such as, "I don't know why I did that." >"Maybe you wanted to." "I don't think I did." Sheesh. But I loved Lois >jumping into a river because she thinks CK=S. And the brush line. >"Where's my brush? Where's my brush? God, not only have I lost my mind, >I've lost my brush!" And the bellboy saying "Have a happy...whatever." >The movie had the potential to be so much better. And I think that >Teri's Lois would react better than Margot's Lois. And I think I would >have to use the whole ice palace Fortress of Solitude. Sorry, but L&C >wouldn't fit in a treehouse! And I think that Dean's Clark could >have beat up that creep in the diner even without powers, although that >would lose the scene in the end that was so funny. I think it's an even >trade, not to have to see CK get beat up. And I bet I could have a >little fun with the kissing contest Lois mentions in Superman 2.... >Does anybody have any ideas for the story? > >********************************************************* >"Lois, get a grip!" "Ooh, believe me, I'd love to!" ;) >~~>Susan<~~ >******************************************************** > =-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-= | Gary A. Rudick mailto:gar8434@rit.edu | | "You decide what you feel heaven is worth" - Deborah Gibson, TWYH | =-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-= ========================================================================= Date: Wed, 24 Sep 1997 00:02:25 -0400 Reply-To: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" Sender: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" Comments: RFC822 error: Incorrect or incomplete address field found and ignored. From: Pam Jernigan Subject: Re: Reading (was Re: Ideas) MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable Content-Type: text/plain; charset=ISO-8859-1 While wandering down memory lane, Genevieve wrote: >> Likewise in later years I wore out Elysyth Thane's "Williamsburg novels", << Have to chime in - I *adore* Elswyth Thane, especially the Williamsburg novels... okay, so I'm not so fond of Yankee Stranger, but then I generally dislike Civil War settings - must be a side effect of hating "Gone With the Wind" My favorites are "Ever After" and "Homin= g" - and I have to nominate "The Light Heart" as the most mis-titled book I'= ve ever come across, I found it *really* depressing - Genevieve, no doubt yo= u loved it I haven't read them in a while, since I've been unlucky in finding copies outside of libraries Oh, and reading "Tryst" by her was the most magical, wonderful, enchanted afternoon I've ever enjoyed - something in it really touched me= =2E = (If anyone out there has this book and would be willing to sell or lend i= t - please e-mail me :-) And while we're discussing novels that really captivate you and paint a reality more convincing than your own, I have to include "Trade Wind" b= y M.M. Kaye. >> more proof that we are all "kindred spirits" in a way. << It's funny... among my local FOLC group, a significant minority also love reading Georgette Heyer PJ !^NavFont02F04090026MGnHG3BMG43HG82MG84HJ82MJ84HJB0MJB2HKQ43F0 E-mail from: Pam Jernigan, 23-Sep-1997 jernigan@compuserve.com / ChiefPam on the IRC ~~~~~ Unreformed, unrepentent, sometimes unproductive but never uninteresting fanfic writer = Visit Sarah & Pam's Shrine o'Fanfic at: http://www.geocities.com/hollywood/2501 ~~~~~ Lois and Clark Season 5 Fanfic: http://www.fortunecity.com/tattooine/mothership/60/season5.htm ~~~~~ "The first thing she said to me was 'Herbie, get me to the Planet.' Naturally, I wondered which planet..." ========================================================================= Date: Wed, 24 Sep 1997 00:02:27 -0400 Reply-To: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" Sender: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" Comments: RFC822 error: Incorrect or incomplete address field found and ignored. From: Pam Jernigan Subject: A fanfic idea MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable Content-Type: text/plain; charset=ISO-8859-1 While flipping channels, Susan E VanCott wrote >> Did anyone else notice the similarities between HIM and Superman 2? <= < Yeah, I did, sort of... okay, mostly I noticed how much the blunt plot devices annoyed me. But actually, the storyline would work much better with Teri & Dean; I could never believe that the movie's Lois would be happy with "just Clark", which is what she got. Now there's a fanfic idea - if L&C determined that having sex would kill her, but there was a way to rid CK of his powers... would they do it? PJ rambling happily :-) !^NavFont02F01D30017MGHHG3DMG3FHG78MG7AHHD4C82D E-mail from: Pam Jernigan, 23-Sep-1997 jernigan@compuserve.com / ChiefPam on the IRC ~~~~~ Unreformed, unrepentent, sometimes unproductive but never uninteresting fanfic writer = Visit Sarah & Pam's Shrine o'Fanfic at: http://www.geocities.com/hollywood/2501 ~~~~~ Lois and Clark Season 5 Fanfic: http://www.fortunecity.com/tattooine/mothership/60/season5.htm ~~~~~ "The first thing she said to me was 'Herbie, get me to the Planet.' Naturally, I wondered which planet..." ========================================================================= Date: Wed, 24 Sep 1997 01:21:18 -0400 Reply-To: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" Sender: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" From: Barbara Garonzik Subject: Re: Reading In a message dated 97-09-23 14:14:59 EDT, you write: << This came in today's PEOPLE email newsletter: >> How do you get this newsletter? Barb ========================================================================= Date: Wed, 24 Sep 1997 03:40:48 -0400 Reply-To: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" Sender: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" From: The Zoomway Subject: Re: Ideas In a message dated 97-09-23 17:39:27 EDT, NightSky@EROLS.COM writes: << Divorce, cheating, death -- they would all put our favorite characters under a lot of stress, and different aspects of their characters. >> Rarer still among the "cheating" stories is the character not being able to get over it, get past it. Inevitably forgiveness follows the "gut-wrenching" agony. If Clark cheated on Lois, I would expect Lois to try, but fail at ever truly getting over the betrayal. Since cheating in general goes completely against everything we've seen established for Clark's character, it still becomes something pretty hard for me to swallow anyway, but supposing he cheated, I'd believe a story where Lois decides it's not fair to either of them to try and make it work anymore. I'm not a fan of "Friends" per se, but I did see the episode where one character wants to get back with his girlfriend after cheating on her, and she just can't forgive him. She can't get past it. It's the ultimate betrayal and in a manner is a humilation to the person who is cheated on (was she prettier, was she sexier, was she better in bed). If Clark or Lois were to degrade the other in this manner, then maybe not being able to make it work would be the most satisfying story for me, but ya know what? I wouldn't read it anyway For me L&C are special, and the problems they face aren't the problems everyone else faces. They have to work ten times as hard just to make some semblance of a relationship work, and for that reason alone they're more admirable to me and more "gut wrenching" moments can be achieved with them simply trying to make something work that nobody in the history of the world has had to try and make work. I'm not saying that devices or cliches like cheating or death of a character being used to elicit hand-wringing angst can't be good. I remember one of the much older fanfic stories about the death of a very aged Superman that was very touching and it worked well. As for a story with great impact without having to go the route of cheating or death in order to create a situation that tests the characters, there was Sheila Harper's "A Shot in the Dark" which I thought was excellent and challenged Lois and Clark even in a sexual sense (Lois had been paralysed by a gunshot wound) So I think for me something that challenges them while still keeping them in character works a lot better. Again, just for me personally. >>>There's been very little fanfic written about one of the more interesting parts of the legend to me -- Superman's refusal to kill. How high a price will he pay the keep his hands clean, what would push him accross that line? How would he react after he killed someone, and how would Lois react? Would she blame him, comfort him, try to justify it in his eyes?<<<< As long as it's not handled as abysmally as the season premier of Millennium. The revamp called for the loss of the wife and daughter so they worked out a separation plot line that will audience-test the reaction to a 'single' Frank Black and his new cohorts at the Millennium group. Anyway, for those of you who were fortunate enough to miss the premier, Frank's wife was kidnapped by a "talking head" whacko and then Frank finally finds her, the guy springs out of the darkness with a knife and attacks Frank. Frank gets the knife and kills the kidnapper. The wife is appalled...I mean guy, she is like totally bummed, he truly bent her aura with that one She told him that she couldn't live with him and needed some space about how she had to think of their daughter and if a man who would do what Frank did was a good dad. I told my husband after the wife's reaction "If a whacko ever kidnaps me and keeps me chained in basement, feel free to blow his !@#$ing head off!" ;) >>>Zoomway's latest even gave him back his secret identity with a seeing eye dog. No one has really examined what Superman would be like in the Alt-Universe<<< That *was* my take on how his life would be in the Alternate universe I had him facing a new protest group every day and having someone who has to schedule his appearances at charities, awards, etc. Having such a high profile person who attracts protesters had the neighbors on Clinton Street disappearing little by little and Clark is hurt when he discovers that fact. I had him losing his job at the Planet simply because his continued presence there was disruptive and the competing papers cried foul saying he was unfair competition. I think everyone has their own "motive" for certain story lines. I think right now you'll see stories where alt Clark finds alt Lois, and later there will be stories of a different nature about the alternate Clark and his world. I had a lot of issues I wanted settled for alt Clark. I wanted him to have a private life restored. I wanted Lois to do that for him because if not for her he'd have never lost that to begin with. I wanted a touch of a tribute to the silver age Superman, and so the "regular guy" became the disguise in the alternate world. I wanted the sexual tension established in Tempus Anyone and Lois and Clarks resolved by *that* couple. To accomplish that I had to make the alternate Lois hidden within (merged with) the Lois we've all seen for four years and thus retaining her memories. In reality there could be a lot of "takes" on the Alternate Clark. He could become a tyrant, a broken man, a recluse, a pawn for the military and dozens of other scenarios (many covered in the comics in Elseworld stories and annuals) >>>I have visions of a lonely Clark, living in a secure penthouse (sort of like Luthor's<<< I toyed with Clark living such an existence, but since I strongly felt Superman (once outed by Tempus) would be the target of various protest groups, and perhaps even radical groups (his apartment was blown up in my story) then I felt a highrise penthouse arrangement would be impossible. Who'd want to rent the rest of that building? Also, I didn't want to go the Batman-type "Dark Knight" loner for Clark. That too was done in the comics in "Speeding Bullets". I think that being more of a Lois fan, I tend to go more with stories that test her, rather than Clark. Those who are bigger Clark fans will do stories that test him. It's not *always* the case with me, since Counter Clark-Wise was a test of Clark throughout the story, but often I like highlighting Lois since the series is the only medium that has ever made Lois as important to the legend as Superman himself. >>>putting communication satellites into orbit for the Rudolph Murdoch's of the world for a significant sum, and agonizing over whether to sign a contract with the Defense Department<<<< Stories where someone who is "not like us" being outed and the aftermath of that has been a staple on TV. In "Bewitched" Samantha gives Darren a dream of what their life would be like if they told eveyone she was a witch. Well, almost immediately there were bleachers set up outside the Stephens' home. Bus tours included their home on their route. The military basically asked that Wizard of Oz classic question "Are you a good witch, or a bad witch?" Okay, they asked if she was an "American" witch. Samantha and Tabitha were moved to a military installation for protection and study. I can see all of this more or less happening to alt Clark, but I'd feel like I was ripping off American sitcom heaven to do it ;) There was also "Mork & Mindy" saying that Mork was an alien, holding a TV press conference, and doing a stint on Tom Snyder. An interesting take happened on "My Favorite Martian" Martin's nephew Andromeda visited him and he was very gungho Martian and didn't believe in pretending to be an "Earthling" He basically blabs that he's a Martian and proves it, and the planet goes into abject panic at the idea that there are aliens here on Earth. They literally are under seige in the episode. They are seen as a threat to everything from mom's apple pie to national security. These were all one-shot episodes, and so had nothing approaching a lasting impact on the balance of the series, but neither did *they* address tough questions. I've always felt if intelligent life were found somewhere besides Earth, there would be far reaching implications and many of them would be philosophical and religious. I battle between extremes when contemplating our government having covered up UFO confirmations. First, I can imagine the military trying to "spare" us the truth, for whatever reason, but I can't imagine a race of beings so intelligent that they can build spacecraft that can traverse the known galaxy being *caught* by the military. I proposed a story that would have Superman discovered as a complete and utter hoax perpetrated by a scientific consortium who wanted to run the ultimate test in "behaviorism" What if it were discovered that Superman was a normal infant who had been treated with some formula that would turn him into a "super" man as he grew? How would Superman be viewed after the truth came out? How would Clark view himself? >>>>Stories that *end* with the divorce are the depressing ones. Although occasionally, as with Rhett and Scarlett, one can only say "it's about time!" when the marriage *finally* breaks up.<<< With Rhett and Scarlet (as with a lot of romance of that genre and era) it is almost a done deal from opening to close that their "love" (if it can be called that) is doomed. With Lois and Clark, their destiny lies in another direction, at least for me, or they become just one more star-crossed set of lovers like Vincent and Catherine, Heathcliff and Cathy (wow, it might work if it were titled Cathy and Clark ;) where the angst flows like cheap gin at the Ace o' Clubs It's not that I have anything against melodrama or gothic "doomed" romance, but sometimes they are so unrelenting that you'd personally volunteer to kill them both just to have it over with. I don't like soap operas, and they tend to have cheating and death angst all the time....oh...and amnesia Zoomway@aol.com ========================================================================= Date: Wed, 24 Sep 1997 04:33:32 -0400 Reply-To: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" Sender: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" From: Peace Everett Subject: Re: Reading (was Re: Ideas) Hmmm.... what do I read when I'm not reading fanfic? Well, up until about a year ago (which is when I got into FoLCdom) I was working on a complete collection of the Star Trek novels -- at last count I had something like 200 from the various book series -- Classic, Next Gen, DS9, Voyager, Starfleet Academy, DS9 Boys. I've got a copy of the very first Star Trek novel ever published -- a children's novel entitled Mission to Horatius. I also have a numbered copy (First Edition) of Hamlet Prince of Denmark, the Restored Klingon Version , as well as a large number of Trek-related books. I've read almost all of Clive Cussler's books -- his Raise the Titanic hooked me and I thoroughly enjoyed all the others up to his most recent, which he must have been asleep when he wrote -- it lacks his usual style. I went through a phase of being really into Alistair McLean -- mainly because my brother was really into them, but I haven't read anything of his in ages. I also went through a phase of reading stacks of Harlequins, but I got over that real fast! I've read some of Marion Zimmer Bradley, but not recently. I have a whole stack of Barbara Hambly that I got at a garage sale and haven't gotten to yet. What else have I read recently? Dawning. Oh, wait, that's fanfic ;) Hunt for Red October. Lost Moon (on which Apollo 13) was based. Quantum Leap novels, which don't come out nearly often enough to suit me. People have mentioned some of my favorites from years gone by: Pride and Prejudice, The Scarlet Pimpernel, A Wrinkle in Time. As a teenager I got hooked on C.S. Lewis' Chronicles of Narnia and read the entire series through many times -- I still love those stories. A few years back I found them in Portuguese and got to brush up my skills in that language reading them again. Peace ========================================================================= Date: Wed, 24 Sep 1997 05:47:12 -0600 Reply-To: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" Sender: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" From: Debby Stark Subject: Clark Fic Mime-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset="us-ascii" At 04:35 PM 9/23/97 -0500, Genevieve wrote: [snip interesting stuff about ideas...] >There's been very little fanfic written about one of the more interesting >parts of the legend to me -- Superman's refusal to kill. How high a price >will he pay the keep his hands clean, what would push him accross that >line? How would he react after he killed someone, and how would Lois >react? Would she blame him, comfort him, try to justify it in his eyes? If the world saw that he had done it, would 99% of the population be on his side but what would Lois and his folks think? Even if they thought it justified, how do they react to how he surely thinks about it? >One of the things that has surprised me is that in our ever-growing mountain >of fanfic dealing with Alt-Clark, almost all of it, if not all of it, choose >the WAFFy way, pairing him up with Alt-Lois or Clone Lois. Zoomway's latest >even gave him back his secret identity with a seeing eye dog. No one has >really examined what Superman would be like in the Alt-Universe. I have >visions of a lonely Clark, living in a secure penthouse (sort of like >Luthor's), putting communication satellites into orbit for the Rudolph >Murdoch's of the world for a significant sum, and agonizing over whether to >sign a contract with the Defense Department. I did this a bit in my Argh rewrite. I could see him bereft of real friends (everyone but the villains fawns on him) and he tires of that rapidly. Without anyone to pour his heart out to, which he'd had, in a way, with Lana and maybe the Langs, I could see him getting cynical and standoffish. I'd still rescue people, but I could see him delivering stern lectures, too :) >Now it could be argued that those types of stories are not "Lois and Clark" >fanfic, but just plain "Clark" fanfic, and perhaps they are. They don't >lend themselves to WAFFs easily, that's for sure. But they could explore >some unexplored areas. Clark Fic is an interesting term. I'd like to explore more of Clark's life and journeys/adventures before he decided to give Metropolis a try. Whenever I think up an idea for this, though, I tend to think: where the heck am I going to put Lois? Should I try to give her equal time? Does it matter? What could Lois have done at this age that wsa as interesting? Is this post to ask if it's all right to do pure Clark Fic? Would a general "okay" also apply to pure Lois Fic? Would I obey a general negative reply if I had a good idea? Is it too early in the morning (5:25am) to be asking such questions? ;) Debby Debby@swcp.com trying to remember what reading hard copy is like so she can reply to the "what do you read" thread... ========================================================================= Date: Wed, 24 Sep 1997 05:47:14 -0600 Reply-To: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" Sender: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" From: Debby Stark Subject: Re: Reading (was Ideas) Mime-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset="us-ascii" I recall that in either late junior high or early High School, we were given the choice of several novels to read as a group. I picked Moby Dick (no doubt and abriged version) but can't remember much about it, so it was probably in junior high (before it became "midschool") (before Dean was born)... For non internet-derived reading now...? Magazines and local newspapers I can skim through usually. I'm just finishing a 2-year-old copy of the British travel magazine "Wander Lust", which I picked up to get ideas for a traveling CK (with or w/o Lois). Great magazine! I read in the bathroom a lot ;) I have stacks of books I haven't read and will eventually (when there's no more electricity and internet access, I guess). For example, I have books on martial arts and Taoism; the Alien Nation novels; books by Spike Milligan and P. G. Woodhouse; and a collection of "Wrapped in Plastic," a magazine dedicated to Twin Peaks; some occult horror (Koontz, Skipp and Spectre, Reeves-Stevens). And more. Recently Read Fiction: "The Cat Who..." books by Lilian Jackson Braun. Light mystery with realistic cats as heros. The author really researches her topics, the things she has her hero become interested in, and I like her style. Also at the library sales room (a great place to get back issues of unusual magazines) I picked monthly SF and Mystery compilations in magazines. and Nonfiction: "The Secret School," by Whitley Strieber. I'll read anything by him, fiction or nonfiction. He has a site, too, www.strieber.com :) I suppose we'll all be checking to see if Anne Rice has written anything for Rag & Bone yet... Debby Debby@swcp.com ========================================================================= Date: Wed, 24 Sep 1997 07:53:29 -0700 Reply-To: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" Sender: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" From: Vicki Krell Subject: Re: A fanfic idea MIME-version: 1.0 Content-type: text/plain; charset="iso-8859-1" And what was the deal with Margot Kidder's mouth? Was it just me, or did it look like she was wearing dentures? Her teeth looked too big for her mouth. And I agree, Dean's Clark would have beat the crap out of a protagonist, at least he did on the show when he was without his powers. Vicki -----Original Message----- From: Gary [SMTP:gar8434@RITVAX.ISC.RIT.EDU] Sent: Tuesday, September 23, 1997 6:55 PM To: LOISCLA-GENERAL-L@LISTSERV.INDIANA.EDU Subject: Re: A fanfic idea Hmmmm....Let's see honeymoon suite, ice palace, diner fight, and Clark gets to squeeze Lois' oranges...sounds like a fanfic waiting to be written! At 08:49 PM 9/23/97 -0400, you wrote: >Well, it's been a couple days since I saw Honeymoon in Metropolis again, >and I had a kind of a thought. Did anyone else notice the similarities >between HIM and Superman 2? L&C have to go undercover as a married >couple in a honeymoon suite. The bellboy makes cracks at them. Okay, >maybe there aren't THAT many similarites, but the big one is there: L&C >being an undercover married couple at a honeymoon suite. I think it >would be awesome to combine the movie and the ep. There were parts of >the movie that I just didn't like, such as "Don't you know this is >killing me?" prompting CK to erase Lois' memory of his secret. ARGHH! >And there were some stupid lines such as, "I don't know why I did that." >"Maybe you wanted to." "I don't think I did." Sheesh. But I loved Lois >jumping into a river because she thinks CK=S. And the brush line. >"Where's my brush? Where's my brush? God, not only have I lost my mind, >I've lost my brush!" And the bellboy saying "Have a happy...whatever." >The movie had the potential to be so much better. And I think that >Teri's Lois would react better than Margot's Lois. And I think I would >have to use the whole ice palace Fortress of Solitude. Sorry, but L&C >wouldn't fit in a treehouse! And I think that Dean's Clark could >have beat up that creep in the diner even without powers, although that >would lose the scene in the end that was so funny. I think it's an even >trade, not to have to see CK get beat up. And I bet I could have a >little fun with the kissing contest Lois mentions in Superman 2.... >Does anybody have any ideas for the story? > >********************************************************* >"Lois, get a grip!" "Ooh, believe me, I'd love to!" ;) >~~>Susan<~~ >******************************************************** > =-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-= | Gary A. Rudick mailto:gar8434@rit.edu | | "You decide what you feel heaven is worth" - Deborah Gibson, TWYH | =-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-= ========================================================================= Date: Wed, 24 Sep 1997 10:14:22 -0500 Reply-To: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" Sender: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" From: Alyssa Mondelli Organization: Brought to you by the legal firm of Deceive, Inveigle, & Obfuscate Subject: Re: Reading (was Re: Ideas) MIME-version: 1.0 Content-type: text/plain; charset=us-ascii Content-transfer-encoding: 7bit > Hmmm.... what do I read when I'm not reading fanfic? Lots of nonfiction, especially nonfiction in narrative form. Jonathan Harr's "A Civil Action" and John Berendt's "Midnight in the Garden of Good and Evil" are two recent examples that I adored. And travel narratives are one of my special favorites. Michael Crichton's "Travels" is an old friend; I'm currently reading Jeff Greenwald's "The Size of the World". Science fact and fiction... right now the shelf of things to be read in my (ha!) copious free time includes some theoretical physics, some speculative fiction, and several sf stories that I've been told I *have* to read. (Just finished "Ender's Game" yesterday - do I qualify as a true sf fan now? :->) I have a soft spot for mysteries dating back to junior high, when my friend Val introduced me to Perry Mason and we set out to find and read all 85 novels. (Never did, but we came darn close...) I've lost interest in Sue Grafton's alphabet series, but I still love Karen Kijewski's Kat Colorado mysteries (though the recent ones have been lacking) and Lillian Jackson Braun's The Cat Who... series. Authors I will follow anywhere: Barbara Kingsolver, Anna Quindlen, Dave Barry, Toni Morrison, Douglas Adams, David Simon. And my single favorite book? Norton Juster's "The Phantom Tollbooth". If you've never read it, your life is incomplete. Go find it in the children's section of your favorite bookstore or library *now*. ==Alyssa in St. Paul== (agmondelli@stthomas.edu)(AlyssaM on the IRC) http://www.fortunecity.com/tattooine/mothership/60/index.htm shameless plug: See my Library page for even more book recommendations ========================================================================= Date: Wed, 24 Sep 1997 19:04:37 +0000 Reply-To: dom-mel@dial.pipex.com Sender: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" Comments: Authenticated sender is From: Dom Melaragni Subject: Re: Reading, Writing & 'Rithmetic . . . oops wrong In-Reply-To: <199709240138.VAA07874@aus-e.mp.campus.mci.net> MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-type: text/plain; charset=US-ASCII Content-transfer-encoding: 7BIT >Oh, and then there are the Scots. Would I like Clark in a > kilt? Ya bet ya, I would. The campaign continues Latest theory is...... Planet Hollywood are scheduled to open in Edinburgh soon. I'm considering writing to them to tell them that all the stars should be in kilts and btw, why don't they invite Dean .....a Flying Scotsman! Dom - go look at Jackie's website for lots of pictures of Dean in a kilt - http://ds.dial.pipex.com/jacmac ================================================================= Dom Melaragni (FlakeyDom) The LnC drinking game and Fest pics http://ds.dial.pipex.com/dom-mel/index.htm ?8-)] Clark Kent smiley with the superhero squarejaw chin ========================================================================= Date: Wed, 24 Sep 1997 11:18:26 -0700 Reply-To: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" Sender: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" From: Sara Kraft Subject: Re: Clark Fic Mime-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset="us-ascii" Debby Stark wrote: >Clark Fic is an interesting term. I'd like to explore more of Clark's life >and journeys/adventures before he decided to give Metropolis a try. Whenever >I think up an idea for this, though, I tend to think: where the heck am I >going to put Lois? Should I try to give her equal time? Does it matter? What >could Lois have done at this age that wsa as interesting? Is this post to >ask if it's all right to do pure Clark Fic? Would a general "okay" also >apply to pure Lois Fic? Would I obey a general negative reply if I had a >good idea? Is it too early in the morning (5:25am) to be asking such >questions? ;) I've read several Clark fics and thoroughly enjoyed them. In fact, I think they were some what of a series by this wonderful lady named Margaret Brignell. I found that I was able to understand the present Clark much better with reading his background. Margaret writes Clark wonderfully, his emotions and mannerisms and such. I've also just finished reading "When a Great Man Loves a Super Woman" by Ben Pistorius, which was a Lois fic (of course as the title indicates, with a slightly different twist). So in answer to Debby's question, yes it's okay with me to do pure Clark fic and pure Lois fic. Sara Kraft (tmax@azstarnet.com), who can't wait to find some free time in which to read TUFS #1 and the new Dawning. ========================================================================= Date: Wed, 24 Sep 1997 11:18:16 -0700 Reply-To: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" Sender: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" From: Vicki Krell Subject: Re: Reading, Writing & 'Rithmetic . . . oops wrong Comments: To: dom-mel@dial.pipex.com MIME-version: 1.0 Content-type: text/plain; charset="iso-8859-1" Dom, I keep trying to send you an e-mail but it never goes through. If you can, please e-mail me at Vicki.Krell@ASU.Edu. It's about flakes and the fanfic you wrote (at least, I THINK you wrote it!!). Thanks! -----Original Message----- From: Dom Melaragni [SMTP:dom-mel@DIAL.PIPEX.COM] Sent: Wednesday, September 24, 1997 12:05 PM To: LOISCLA-GENERAL-L@LISTSERV.INDIANA.EDU Subject: Re: Reading, Writing & 'Rithmetic . . . oops wrong >Oh, and then there are the Scots. Would I like Clark in a > kilt? Ya bet ya, I would. The campaign continues Latest theory is...... Planet Hollywood are scheduled to open in Edinburgh soon. I'm considering writing to them to tell them that all the stars should be in kilts and btw, why don't they invite Dean .....a Flying Scotsman! Dom - go look at Jackie's website for lots of pictures of Dean in a kilt - http://ds.dial.pipex.com/jacmac ================================================================= Dom Melaragni (FlakeyDom) The LnC drinking game and Fest pics http://ds.dial.pipex.com/dom-mel/index.htm ?8-)] Clark Kent smiley with the superhero squarejaw chin ========================================================================= Date: Wed, 24 Sep 1997 20:18:00 -0600 Reply-To: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" Sender: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" From: Debby Stark Subject: Re: Reading (was Ideas) Mime-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset="us-ascii" At 12:48 PM 9/22/97 CST, you wrote: >Not much time for reading books anymore, but I did manage to fit one >in about a month ago. It was a Tony Hillerman mystery. Can't >remember the name of the specific book but his are always good. >Kay II Tony, an exOklahoman, lives here in Albuquerque and I've heard him speak (it was a brown-lunch-bag talk at the University: "What would you say if this were your last speech?). Funny guy--Excellent writer. His descriptions of the desert are marvelous. His mysteries are well thought out and riviting, and his characters are always interesting. The Navajos and the Hopi think he does a good job writing them into his novels. Debby Debby@swcp.com who can recommend Tony Hillerman, too :) ========================================================================= Date: Wed, 24 Sep 1997 20:18:45 -0600 Reply-To: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" Sender: "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Fanfic" From: Debby Stark Subject: Re: Looking for Lois Lane Mime-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset="us-ascii" At 05:15 AM 9/22/97 -0400, you wrote: >In a message dated 97-09-21 21:20:26 EDT, debby@SWCP.COM writes: [snip my scenario about Jack] >To quote alternate Clark "This is exactly what I was afraid of" That >sounds awfully close to Batman and his boy companion Robin ;) I was glad Jack >vanished. Only if Clark knew about it, but I think Jack would wisely have kept it to himself. I liked Jack. I like characters with promise (I'll make them promising) who enhance the main characters :) That's why I was disappointed as the number of continuing characters dwindled. >>>>Some argue that he hadn't had a steady relationship before, and this may >be the case<<< >"Flying is a piece of cake. I've been doing it since high school. What >happens if I screw up? I lose a little altitude, but being in a relationship, >that's completely new..." So, yes, that was the case. He never had a >relationship by his own admission. Ah, but he took Rachel to the prom. In Honeymoon in Metropolis, both of them admitted to not having lived with anyone. I suspect by "relationship" he meant the kind he wanted to have with Lois. I suspect he had quite a few girlfriends. After all, he didn't learn to kiss like he was able to (and he sure wasn't shy about endulging in it) from his mom... >>>>However, I don't think this translates into the relationship he wants >being hard to maintain. If he had not yet had such a relationship of his own, let's >look at the most influenial relationship he experienced through observation, >that of Martha and Jonathan<<<< > >How much worth was his parents as examples when it came to a courtship? Clark >didn't know what his parents dating history was like. If anything, I think >Clark's idealized vision of his parents relationship sometimes caused some >unrealistic expectations for him.. He wanted instant 'happily ever after', >but because he only saw the "after" with his parents, he had absolutely no >clue what they went through to achieve that. We know that he didn't know that his dad had to ask his mom 4 times. But as far as I know, that's all he knew about their history (which is a little hard for me to believe). However, having high expectations doesn't mean unrealistic expectations. Instead, to me it means he had hope. Unfortunately(?) for him, he tried his hopes on Lois, who's parents went through hard times. *That* part was hard on him. Was it hard because his parents' romance was atypical or because Lois's parents' romance was? Difficult to say... >>>>Clark could have solve that by simply telling Lois the truth<<< > >Telling Lois the truth only solved part of the problem (his dashing off >appearing to be a fear of commitment, etc) but it still didn't give him >relationship skills, and no matter how good an example Jon and Martha were, >Jon was never two people who had to balance a job, being a superhero and a >marriage. Martha didn't have to adjust to something like that either. Lois >and Clark were on their on with that scenario. I still don't see the difficulty. Once she knows why he rushes off, then what's difficult? She would still get into trouble all the time even if he weren't super because it's unlikely she'd give up her job just to get married. It's the same as before, when both of them were still willing to make the commitment. No, I still don't see why he had this trouble. I can understand her wariness, just not his. He must have thought he could make it work or he wouldn't have proposed to her. What made it so difficult after that? Was it Lois having to think about it and not saying yes right away? Maybe. But where did CK get that sulky attitude? (poor writing?) (yes) Was it Lois abandoning her independent ways and assuming he'd always be there to rescue her and thus throwing herself into dangerous situations? (Contact) Maybe. (that never made sense to me anyhow; a plot device --a "road block.") So to stop her from doing that, he dumped her. Huh? I guess all this is because "he didn't have any experience"... but his way of expressing his lack of experience sure never made any sense to me... >>>blundered into his relationship >with Lois Lane and came out looking like a heavily stressed chunk of >granite<<< >I enjoyed their "blunders". It made their bliss all the more well earned ;) What bliss? Those little bits wedge in between the villains explaining their next move? I think we can agree we would rather have seen more bliss than bandits. >>>hen, seeing that his mind was made up and that he was going to make his >announcement the next day, Lois rushed out to find a better solution. Which, >of course, she did. Hooray, Lois<<< > >I think ultimately the decision has to be Clark's. I know it's supposed to be >50/50 in a marriage,. but there are some points where one partner has the >ultimate decision to make and stand by. If a wife doesn't want any more >children, but the husband does, I say ultimately *she* makes the decision >because she is the one who has to endure the pregnancy. I agree. >Now, if both men and >women could get pregnant, that would be different. The wife could say, "Okay, >you want another baby? It's your turn to get pregnant." Amen (A women, too) >Lois had a great deal to do with the creation and the maintainance of >"Superman", but when push comes to shove, Clark is the one all alone out >there having to make the decisions by himself, often in a split second. Agreed, except this particular decision wasn't one made in a split second. >Jon and Martha made great points about Lois and Clark losing their privacy and >Lois being known from there on out as "Superman's wife", and they politely didn't mention that their own lives would be in jeopardy from then on... >but Lois accepts >what might befall her and Clark if the truth comes out, what she *can't* >accept is what happens to Superman if the truth comes out. She's trying to >let Clark know that the truth could be as bad or worse for "Superman" as the >scandal. Superman's "fate" can be discussed and argued by all parties who >might be effected by "the truth", but ultimately the decision can't be made >by committee, it is up to one person--Clark Kent. Who, from how I saw it, failed to take all of this into account. The effect on his own parents alone I feel should have prompted him to talk it all out with them before coming to any major decision. However, it made for "melodrama," and talking heads aren't interesting, so we got him going off to prepare and Lois rushing off to save the day (hooray!!) >>>It took her most of the episode to say this, too. Yawn.<<< > >Having been married 16 years, I can tell you that it takes a lot longer than >"most of the episode" sometimes to tell your husband what's upsetting you. >This phrase, "Well, if you don't know what's wrong, I'm certainly not going >to tell you" didn't become a cliche from lack of use ... >...One reason Lois drew the whole >thing out is because she thought Clark knew about his molecular structure >"stablizing and slowing" the aging process and she was angry he never told >her. Thus making my argument for her to simply ask him about it. Did she think he was purposefully keeping it from her? If not, all the more reason to simply ask him. But that wasn't dramatic enough. >>>>That's not what was said, that much I recall. His body had already >compensated. It had made up the difference, he had revitalized, he was the same as >before.<<< >Well, here's the dialog, make of it what you will, but to me it sounds like >Clark did "lose something". > >"Dr. Klein said my body has already compensated for the age drain." >"Compensated? Then you have lost something." >"My friend is healthy. I'm sitting here with my wife. I haven't lost anything." >"You gave up years." >"I gave them up for a friend." >"How many?" >"I don't know. The truth is, no one knows how long they've got. Anyway, it's >not the years that count, it's the moments. Right now, as they happen." I heard: "Dr. Klein said my body has already compensated for the age drain." She went on to say "You gave up years.... how many" He said "I don't know." >You'll recall right after Superman came out of the machine (after resetting >Carter Shank to infancy and Jimmy back to a 22 year old) he said "I feel >okay" Lois asks Doodsen "Is he?" and she says "It's too soon to tell" I go with Klein, who knows Superman pretty well, than Doodsen, who didn't know him at all. > Remember that Jimmy looked fine right after he came out of the machine and >the rapid aging took a while to start. Superman looked fine right when he >came out, but because of his long lifespan, then even the 100+ years it cost >him to restore Shank (over restore him ;) and Jimmy was something his body >could "compensate" (counterbalance). It doesn't matter, Jimmy and Shank are both human. Supes isn't. >That is, suppose you have a 50 year old man (want one? ;) depends ;) that is, if he's not wearing them ;) >and you age him >five years. It's not likely that it'll make that big a difference in his >appearance. However, if you take an infant and age *him* five years, the >difference is startling. What I'm getting at is say that Superman's lifespan >was 200 years, but then you take about 130 from that (to restore Shank and >Jimmy) and his lifespan now becomes 70 years. In other words, Superman still >had 70 years left to him, and so the "drain" wouldn't show on him. Whereas, >you take Jimmy, whose lifespan is about 70 to begin with and take 50 years of >that away from him, then he has no "years" left to compensate the loss. He's >going to be an old man. I don't know if any of that made any sense, but Lois >and Clark's dialog seems to indicate Clark did in fact lose years. No, that doesn't make any sense to me (though I can see it might make good fanfic). What was *said* was: "Dr. Klein said my body has already compensated for the age drain." and Dr. Klein was not only Superman's doctor but was the one Supes went to for the sperm count :) I trust in Klein. >>>>That's my very point. I certainly expect them to *try*, on the ceiling, on >the kitchen floor, or wherever they wanted, and have lots of fun at it! But >to go into the marriage assuming they could have kids<<< >Before they got married, Lois was in the alternate world and Wells helped her >recall their previous adventure, and in that adventure Wells tells Lois that >Superman's descendants create Utopia. Wells also assures her that she "will >be" good at handling babies. Too bad he didn't mention Soulmates or the adoption agency, or Tempus and the time machine trap, the baby from the future, etc. Wells' record wasn't that good... >Then if we go back to The Foundling, perhaps >Clark read too much into Jor-El saying that Earth was chosen because of its >compatability with Krypton and its people. I assume (for fanfic anyhow) that compatibility means that the atmosphere wouldn't kill the baby and probably the human inhabitants might adopt him :) I like the mystery. >Either way, even human couples >assume they can have children until they start trying and nothing happens. "even human," I agree! However, only Lois was human. >>>>I suspect that he did know. I wouldn't expect Clark >to rat on Lois because I would expect Perry to already know about it.<<< > >Okay, let's assume that for whatever reason not indicated in the episode, >Perry knew Lois stole the story and so *he* sent her on that wild goose chase >through the sewage reclamation plant. I wouldn't assume this. I'd have Perry take Lois aside and ask her if she's okay, she doesn't usually upset her coworkers like this. After some heming and hawing she'd breakdown (as she was wont to do) and admit to him (her father figure) that she had no idea what she was doing. He'd counsel her and let her off with a warning :) >>>>Clark, sitting quietly at his desk, speaking from the heart, looking >right at Lois (note that the newsroom is nearly empty). "Lois, I don't >appreciate you stealing other people's stories."<<< > >Even if a more subdued scene had been feasible for the Lois of Neverending >Battle fame, all we'd get really is an apology from her, That's bad? That would be a major step forward! :) >and it still ices out Jimmy's part. Maybe as part of the apology L&C could help Jimmy get the story :) >I think the show handled it well and with good humor, and >Lois knew she had it coming and learned a lesson about underestimating Clark >Kent when he's the victim of story stealing ;) In fairness though, if you >want to rewrite NB, that's okay, as long as I get to rewrite IGACOY ;) Gladly! When I have time ;) Until then, I'd rather just drop IGACOY from the canon ;) >>>>Well, we know where to go to find out what CK's idle fantasies are... >;)<<< > >Are these sexual or non-sexual? ;) Hey, you're the one arguing his having no relationship experience... what kind of fantasies does a guy like that have, hmm? >Zoomway@aol.com (what the heck, it's 4:00a.m., the gutter's open ;) It's 7:38pm here, though I started pretty e